Fireplace or Fire Pit?
There’s something magical about gathering around a fire on a crisp evening. Whether you’re roasting marshmallows, swapping stories, or just soaking up the warmth, a fire feature can transform any outdoor space into a cozy retreat.
But should you go for an outdoor fireplace or a fire pit? Both have their perks, but which one fits your space, budget, and needs best? Let’s break it down.
Bringing the Heat: Which One Warms Better?
Fireplaces look grand and give off a steady warmth, but they mainly heat up a small area. Only a handful of people—usually four to six—can sit comfortably close enough to enjoy the heat. If you want a fireplace to be the star of your backyard, you’ll need outdoor furniture arranged just right.
Fire pits, on the other hand, send heat in all directions. Because they burn in an open space, people can gather all around and still feel the warmth. Even those standing a few steps away can enjoy the heat. If you’re hosting big gatherings or want a casual setup where people can come and go, a fire pit might be the better pick.
Size Matters: Big and Bold or Open and Airy?
An outdoor fireplace makes a statement. It’s a tall, sturdy structure that can serve as a privacy wall or block an unwanted view. If you want something grand that anchors your patio, a fireplace is a solid choice.
A fire pit, on the other hand, is much more open. It sits low to the ground, allowing people to gather around easily. The good news? Fire pits come in a variety of shapes and sizes. Some are simple metal bowls, while others are custom-designed and match any style.
What About the Cost?
Money talks, and when it comes to fire features, there’s a big difference in price.
Fire pits are usually the more budget-friendly option. A high-quality, durable fire pit can range from $200 to $5,000, depending on size and material. (They can be even less if you decide to go with a flatpack model.)
Fireplaces? That’s a whole different story. Because they are built as permanent structures, they require more materials, skilled labor, and sometimes even permits (more on that later). Prices can range anywhere from $4,000 to $24,000.
If cost is a big factor in your decision, fire pits offer a great way to enjoy a fire without breaking the bank.
Rules, Permits, and Paperwork—Oh My!
One big downside to fireplaces? Regulations. Building a fireplace isn’t as simple as stacking bricks and lighting a fire.
The chimney height must be at least two feet taller than any nearby structures.
You’ll need to carefully calculate the flue size to ensure smoke goes up, not back down into your seating area.
Most outdoor fireplaces require a permit, meaning extra paperwork, time, and possibly inspections.
Gas fireplaces add even more complications. Gas lines must be trenched and connected to your home’s gas supply, which means hiring professionals and dealing with more regulations.
Fire pits, on the other hand, are hassle-free. No permits. No complicated codes. Just light it up and enjoy. You can also choose your fuel—natural gas, propane, wood, lava rock, or fire glass—giving you even more flexibility.
See also: Fire Pit Safety Tips You Need to Know
Which One Should You Choose?
The best choice depends on your needs.
Go for a fireplace if:
You want a grand, permanent structure that adds style and privacy.
You don’t mind the extra cost and permit requirements.
You prefer a more controlled, seated experience.
Choose a fire pit if:
You want a budget-friendly, versatile fire feature.
You love the idea of casual, open gatherings where people can sit all around.
You don’t want to deal with permits or building regulations.
Final Thoughts
Both fire pits and fireplaces bring warmth, beauty, and charm to outdoor spaces. The real question is: Do you want a grand centerpiece or a casual fire to gather around? No matter what you choose, you’ll be creating a cozy spot where memories are made and stories are shared.